NCAA Postgraduate Scholarship Recipients
1965   Tom Nicolai

MIAA Al Deal Scholar-Athlete Award
2009-10  Brandon Luczak(Football/Baseball)

All-Americans
2004   Jeremy Vanisacker, Linebacker (D3football.com 2nd team)
2001   Brant Haverdink, Linebacker (Hewlett Packard 3rd team)
2000   Brant Haverdink, Linebacker (USAfootball.com 3rd team)
1999   Jeff Dillingham, Kick Returner (USAfootball.com 3rd team)
1999   Eric Gerwin, Linebacker (USAfootball.com 4th team)
1999   Nick Lachapelle, Defensive Line (USAfootabll.com honorable mention)

MIAA MVP's
1939   Dan Wood, B (Co-MVP)
1956   Bob Urschalitz, B
1999   Eric Gerwin, Defense
2001   Brant Haverdink, Defense
2004   Jeremy Vanisacker, Defense

USA Football All-Star Classic
1997   Lance Sanders
1997   Gregg McDonald

Aztec Bowl Participants
1999   Nick Lachapelle, Defensive Line
2001   Brant Haverdink, Linebacker
2004   Jeremy Vanisacker, Linebacker

Tazón de Estrellas (Bowl of the Stars)
2010   Cory McCain

Division III Football Senior Classic Participants
2009   Brandon Luczak, Quarterback
2009   Jimmy Semelsberger, Wide Receiver