| Excerpts
from Jonas Traxler-Ballew’s Letters from Chiang Mai, Thailand:
Leaving
home: The process of getting ready was very compressed.
I worked at a summer camp in Maine up until a week before I left.
I basically unpacked my bags, washed my woods-scented clothes,
and packed again. I almost immediately found myself on a plane
heading to Los Angeles, which was a bit of culture shock in itself,
as I had spent the previous month and a half taking kids off into
the Maine woods on camping trips, quite separated from civilization.
I quickly went from being a confident, bearded wilderness guide
to a wide-eyed clean-shaven American college student navigating
LAX airport while traveling exactly halfway around the world to
live for the next six months. Definitely a shock to the system.
When the
breakfast on the flight from LA to Taipei was Dim Sum, rather
than a bland muffin and a patty of scrambled eggs, I knew I was
on the right flight.
Leaving
the comfort zone behind: On the flight to Malaysia, I
sat across the aisle from ten or fifteen Muslim men in long tan
frocks with full beards. Someone mentioned that they were Pakistani.
In the past, I would have been pleased to have been in their company,
and interested in speaking with them. In light of world events
in the past year, however, I was suddenly very conscious—in
an uncomfortable way—of being an American . I hate to admit
it, but all the images I have seen on TV of angry Pakistani men
protesting against the U.S. have made me very concerned that I
might be judged and looked-upon poorly simply for being an American.
But these thoughts struck me as a very prejudiced reaction—the
fact that I assumed that they were judging me. I found my assumptions
even more unsettling.
Impressions
of Thailand: On the way out of the airport, I saw a sign
that affirmed everything I had heard about Thailand’s firm
stance on drug trafficking. On a large wooden gateway arching
over the drive was written, “WELCOME TO THAILAND, except
drug traffickers!” Driving home scared me half to death.
Lanes in Thailand are apparently more suggestion than serious
demarcation. The whole road, including the shoulders, was used
by everyone. My host brother (my mother told me he was just getting
his driving permit, which didn’t help settle my nerves)
kept swerving into the oncoming lane to pass cars, or taking to
the shoulder to get around. Motorcyclists zipped by on all sides
of us on small Japanese-made bikes—helmetless, wearing shorts
and sandals. Ralph Nader has clearly never spent much time in
Thailand. At stoplights, motorcycles crept up between the lanes
of cars wherever there was space, until everyone was released
by a green light in a mass rumbling of diesel, and the herd slowly
separated out at different speeds.
Once we turned
off the main road, I was stunned by how narrow the streets were.
All the houses and their yards were surrounded by five-foot walls,
which made the already tiny streets seem even narrower. There
was no more than three feet of clearance on either side of the
car, and these were two-way streets! We had to stop and pull into
people’s driveways three times on the way home from the
airport, in order to let other cars pass. I couldn’t believe
that my brother was navigating an extended cab pickup truck though
those streets.
Soi
dogs: Another thing I noticed immediately was that Thailand
has dogs. Not house pets as you or I know them, but real dogs,
with developed genitalia, eating table scraps and fighting and
mating with each other in the streets, and generally living beyond
the desires of a household. They lie down on the sidewalks, walk
through outdoor restaurants looking for scraps, and cross streets
on their own. They are just part of the landscape here.
My
host family: Arriving in Chiang Mai, I was swiftly rushed
off by my host family. As we walked around collecting our luggage,
all of the families seemed to be hovering about, picking their
student out of the crowd, obviously excited to see us. My host
mother came up to me and took me by the elbow (a Thai way of holding
on to someone affectionately), and introduced herself and my host
brother. She was a short woman with a bright gentle smile and
bobbed permed hair. My host brother was taller than I (which shocked
me, seeing how small his mother was), and was dressed in his school
uniform…
Arriving
at their house was a nervous-making experience for me. I was very
concerned about making a good impression, and a little bit paranoid
about doing something wrong and offending them. I was surprised
by how well my brother spoke English, which was comforting, as
I knew no Thai at all. My host father, though, spoke no English,
and I felt very disconnected from him the whole time I lived with
my family. I have a difficult time staying in other people’s
houses for long periods of time without feeling intrusive, and
not being able to communicate with him just made that worse.
One thing
about Thai culture that I appreciated right from the start was
the emphasis on family togetherness. My host mother lives in a
walled family compound with two of her brothers. Although they
have separate houses, they see one another every day, and are
very involved in one another’s lives. Since my own parents
are divorced, and the various members of my extended family live
hours—or days—apart from one another, I have been
very appreciative of the intactness of my host family. Other people
on the program have had similar experiences with their host families.
Daily
routines: I had a hard time adjusting to my host family’s
schedule at first. They all wake up at the crack of dawn every
day, whereas I tend to go to bed a bit late and sleep in when
I can. One weekend morning, I woke up at 8:00 because I had heard
everyone moving around for an hour already. I met my host uncle
in they kitchen, and he asked me why I sleep so late and told
me I should get up earlier. Not wanting to appear lazy, I’ve
been struggling to change my schedule ever since. I often find
that I do my best thinking and working at night, and my best reflection
while sleeping in the morning, but I made sure that I was up early
enough to at least eat breakfast with my family from then on.
The
language barrier: Language has definitely been the largest
barrier to connecting with people I meet here. So much is expressed
in language that trying to communicate is impossible beyond pointing
at a menu if you cannot speak the language. It is a very isolating
feeling. When I go out with my host brother, I want to interact
with his friends and the people around us, but I have no way to
do so. Furthermore, linguistic subtleties and slang are such that
even after years of study, they may be beyond the grasp of non-native
speakers. Not speaking Thai has made me wholly dependent on my
host brother, who, by age, should be my little brother. When we
go out, especially since I do not know the city yet, I stick to
him like glue. It has been difficult for me to feel so vulnerable
and dependent.
Drinking:
In Thailand, drinking is commonly conducted around a square table
with four or more chairs, and a bottle of whisky in the middle.
Generally, everyone drinks until the bottle is gone, and then,
if they’re still not satisfied, another bottle is purchased
and placed in the middle again. It is generally good drinking
courtesy to stay on with everyone else until the bottle is gone.
A good amount of peer pressure is used to make sure everyone sticks
together to empty the bottle.
A group of
students who live in my dorm run the small convenience store on
the ground level of the dorm. They are constantly drinking together
in this fashion. One day, when returning from dinner, three of
us K students suddenly found ourselves sitting down at the table
with them, whiskey glasses in hand. It was really fun to meet
all of them, as we had spoken with each of them briefly, but had
never hung out together. It was good to be making Thai friends,
which has been one difficult aspect of being on a program where
you study separately from the rest of the university due to language
barriers and scheduling differences. It quickly became apparent,
however, that getting up and leaving would be a difficult task.
I don’t know how many, “Oh, just one more”s
I gave in to, but I was definitely more intoxicated than I had
wanted to be that night. They seemed crushed every time we tried
to get up, pointing at the bottle and saying, “Help us finish
it!” But the bottles kept being replaced with new ones,
and my glass was constantly being refilled as soon as I took my
eye off it for a second. It was clear that this wasn’t going
to end anytime soon. I finally resorted to holding my glass in
my lap and insisting that it was time for me to go to bed (it
being a school night). It was a fun night to be sure, but the
amount of peer pressure and pleading to drink more caught me a
bit off guard. It was especially difficult to put my foot down
as I was concerned with not offending anyone here or seeming ungrateful,
as I hadn’t pitched in any money for all the whiskey I had
consumed.
After that
night, whenever we’d return to the dorm at night while they
were drinking (which they did several times each week), they’d
holler at us to come drink with them again. I’ve often been
very good at weaseling my way out of it when I don’t want
to drink—I’ve even crawled underneath the windows
of the shop, out of sight, up to where the stairs start (which
they found very amusing). But the number of times I gave in for
a drink or two, to hang out and chat, left me feeling in their
debt, hospitality-wise. So I purchased them a bottle of rum and
presented it to them, for which they were all very grateful. This
seemed to make up for all the times I turned them down, or ran
out early on them.
[In
Thailand, the Kalamazoo College students are encouraged (but
not required) to walk through the red light district of Chiang
Mai at night, accompanied by their Resident Director and his
assistant. It is hoped that by speaking with some of the young
women in the so-called sex industry, students will be able to
put a human face on prostitution, and understand that it involves
real people who have few choices in life.]
One of the
hardest aspects of Thai culture for me to adapt to is the prevalence
of prostitution. Prostitution is rampant in Thailand, despite
being officially illegal. It is hard to drive down a street in
the city without seeing brothels, massage parlors, and karaoke
bars with the telltale Christmas lights, tinted windows, and women
sitting outside on benches. It has been estimated that almost
90% of Thai men have used prostitutes in their lives, and it is
not uncommon (or wasn’t a few years ago, anyway) for fathers
to introduce their sons to sex by bringing them to brothels. This
has been especially hard for me to encounter and learn about,
as it flies in the face of my values concerning sex, love, and
affection, not to mention the father and son bonding experience.
One night,
we went down with our Resident Director to the Night Bazaar area
downtown to talk with prostitutes and study the scene on a first-hand
basis. I went into (or, rather, was pulled into) a small bar with
five women standing near the front of the place calling at me
as I walked down the street. I ordered a “lady-drink”
[the price one pays for taking a woman’s time] for one very
beautiful woman and sat down to talk to her. I asked her about
life, how she was doing, whether she had any kids or not, whether
she liked her work, what she does when she’s not at work,
and other questions. She answered my questions and talked to me,
making fun of me for being younger than she was, but she clearly
wasn’t interested in talking. When I asked her what she
wanted to do in the future, she’d joke with me and whisper
in my ear, “You.” The whole time I talked with her,
she was trying to wrap herself around me, tangling her legs with
mine, putting her arms around me, kissing my neck, apparently
desperately wanting to leave with me. What was hardest for me
about the whole experience was just how nice it was. Affection
is wonderful. It is a good thing. I love being touched, hugged,
and kissed, especially by beautiful women. When sincere, these
are all very good things, essential things, which is why the whole
situation seemed so awful to me. Furthermore, she seemed like
someone I would be interested in knowing as a friend, under normal
circumstances; but here she was, throwing herself at me, desperate
for what was in my wallet, feigning attraction and affection.
Especially
hard for me has been the role of foreigners in the industry. Walking
down the Night Bazaar area on any night, you see all sorts of
foreign men, young and old, with very pretty women sitting with
them, or on them. It is assumed here that if a foreign man is
with a Thai woman, she is a prostitute—and that assumption
is alarmingly accurate. Probably the most disturbing aspect of
this is just how many Thai men I’ve spoken with who have
teasingly asked me if I like Thai women, giving me a wink and
a nudge. It is not uncommon for people to assume that the reason
I am studying here is for the prostitution.
Learning
about the situation of the women in the industry—where they
come from, and why they are in this line of work—has been
absolutely heartbreaking. Most of the girls are from poor farming
families, usually from ethnic minority hill tribes. They come
to Chiang Mai seeking better lives, or are even sold by their
families to agents working for brothels in town (often, their
parents aren’t aware of exactly what the girls will be doing).
Given the value placed on virginity and modesty by the cultures
here (which is, ironically, why young virgins are worth so much
to brothel operators), it is hard to think of the psychological
impact prostitution has on the women involved. Furthermore, some
are practically slaves, and others are tied to the industry by
heavy debts. It is a horrible situation. Still others begin prostituting
themselves out of sheer materialism. College women are known to
offer sexual services in order to be able to afford clothes that
would otherwise be unaffordable for them. This intense materialism
is reflected in—or perhaps caused by—the media here,
which are full of images of wealthy Bangkokians and Westerners
living lifestyles far beyond the reach of most Thais.
Wealth
and poverty: I have a hard time dealing with the massive
wealth disparities, particularly in Bangkok. This is especially
hard for me to see as a foreigner, walking around with a $150
camera in his pocket. I am constantly aware of my wealth while
I am here. Though back home I tend to consider myself a poor college
kid, this simply isn’t true. I go to a ridiculously expensive
private college, and I own more clothes that I just use for playing
sports than many people here have in their homes. Being here has
definitely changed my perspective on wants and needs, and my perspective
on wealth.
I just returned
from a trip to a few tribal villages where I interviewed a number
of villagers about their agricultural practices. Many of the people
I interviewed were barely scraping by, living by growing corn
and peanuts for sale at low market prices. One man planted 360
kg. of peanuts last year, but only got a harvest of 17 kg. back.
He is now heavily in debt, and is burning corncobs for cooking
and heating fuel. My monthly stipend while here is probably larger
than what he’ll make in a year. At the village I met many
people in similar situations, fleeing the economic impossibilities
of Burma, with few places to go, and few opportunities. I had
one young father approach me with a can of baby formula, asking
me to read the directions for him because he couldn’t read
Thai. I had a hard time figuring it out as I don’t really
read Thai very well either, but we eventually got it sorted out.
The visit made me feel very guilty for not having gotten an A
in every single class I’ve taken since I was 11, and for
not having a doctorate by now, given the amazing opportunities
that have been handed to me throughout my life. These visits to
the tribal villages were excellent. I was astounded by how warm,
fun and generous every villager I met was, but it was a bit hard
on my heart.
Thai
sports culture: One place where I’ve been very
successful in integrating into Thai culture is on the basketball
court. I often go down to the University’s courts, where
informal pick-up games are played every night. Basketball in Thailand
is a much less competitive activity than it is in the U.S. No
one takes it seriously, and everyone is always playing around
and having fun. I fit right in in this scene, as I hate it when
sports are overly competitive, and I can’t play basketball
well enough to take myself seriously. The value placed on social
harmony and enjoyment was very clear to me while playing basketball,
and I felt very comfortable playing in that atmosphere. It also
helped me make some Thai friend.
Physical
contact: Public displays of affection are an issue in
Thai culture. I have had some difficulty adjusting to this, but
I’m beginning to appreciate it. In the U.S., physical contact
between friends of the opposite sex is very normal, and hugging
your friends is commonplace. One thing I have definitely noticed
here is that Thai people hug much less than Americans do. There
is more handholding, elbow holding, and other touching here, though,
particularly among friends of the same sex, than there is in the
U.S. More distance is maintained among men in the U.S. I rather
like being able to walk down the street arm in arm with a male
friend without drawing any funny looks. Although I miss hugging
my friends, there are other ways of showing affection in Thailand
that I have grown to appreciate, including that "elbow grab."
At one point,
I made a large cultural faux pas with a public display of affection.
Another American student and I were playfully tickling and poking
each other, which was apparently offending some of our Thai student
partners. I was approached by the program director about it, which
shocked me, as what we were doing seemed to me like innocent play
between two friends, and neither of us considered it sexual.
This was
also difficult for me because the problem was presented to me
in a very Thai way. The person who had the concerns didn’t
confront me directly and explain what I was doing wrong. Instead,
the problem was brought to an intermediary, who spoke to me about
it days later. While I understood and appreciated why this was
done, as it would have been embarrassing to have been confronted
about it, I still wasn’t fully aware of what I had done
wrong [since the person speaking to me was passing along someone
else’s comments]. This made it difficult and confusing to
try to correct my behavior.
|